Under a White Sky: The Nature of the Future by Elizabeth Kolbert: A review
Today's scientists are exploring ways to affect the Nature of the future in ways that will correct the damage that we have already done and continue to do to it. Thus, they consider ways to shield the planet from solar heat, control and eradicate invasive species, or direct the flow of rivers in what we consider to be more beneficial or less destructive ways. And all of this is to correct what we have previously done.
A prime example is the Asian carp. The fish was introduced to American waterways in 1963 as a nontoxic way to help clear aquatic weeds. The carp are voracious feeders and in areas, they outcompeted native species until the natives were virtually extirpated. They spread throughout the waterways of the Midwest and up to the Great Lakes. Nearly sixty years later, we are in a battle to clear them out.
The Mississippi River that bisects the country is one of those battlefronts. It has also long been a tinkertoy for the Army Corps of Engineers as they build levees, dredge, and otherwise attempt to direct its flow. Those efforts all too often have had unintended consequences. Just ask New Orleanians.
For me, one of the most fascinating sections of Kolbert's book dealt with the pupfish, rare species of fish endemic to California. There are several distinct species but the Owens pupfish is one of the rarest of the rare and the efforts of scientists and conservationists to protect and preserve the little fish, as related by Kolbert, are nothing short of heroic. I particularly liked the response of one of the scientists who was asked, "What good is a pupfish?" He replied, "What good are you?" Indeed.
Kolbert goes on to discuss the sad history of what we have done and are doing to the coral reefs of the world and of efforts to breed corals that are more resistant to higher temperatures. This is one of those bioengineering projects that hopes to correct or ameliorate the damage we've done. Another is an attempt to essentially breed the invasive cane toads of Australia out of existence. Engrossing stuff.
Kolbert tells all of this in a straightforward way without any alarmist tendencies. She is very good at presenting this timely information in a way that can be absorbed by her readers. At one point, she quotes Horace from 20 B.C.E. He wrote: "Drive out nature though you will with a pitchfork, yet she will always hurry back, and before you know it, will break through your perverse disdain in triumph." Or as a character in a movie once said, "Nature will find a way."
My rating: 4 of 5 stars
I need to get this book and read it.ReplyDelete
You would find it an absorbing read, David.Delete
trying to alter the environment to suit humanity has never gone too well... earth works on a longer schedule, measured by plate tectonics, mostly, which in turn is driven by convection currents in the mantle...ReplyDelete
Exactly. So why can't we leave well enough alone?Delete
Fascinating book and subject. Did you come away from it feeling a little more optimistic about our future or did it make you more nervous about it than you already were?ReplyDelete
I wouldn't say that it really affected my opinion one way or another but it is good to be informed. I think Kolbert and I are pretty much on the same page here.Delete
This is another brilliant review, Dorothy. I'd love to add this one to our naturalist group newsletter, if you would allow it. I know that many others would be interested in hearing your thoughts about this book.Delete
Of course. I'd be honored for you to share it.Delete
This does sound like a very interesting read! Who knew all that was going on?ReplyDelete
It's interesting that we keep trying to "fix" the mess we've made of Nature and too often the result is even more of a mess.Delete
This sounds rather fascinating yet I think it might make me depressed, The world does a lot of talking about climate and environment but the baby steps taken thus far have just not been enough.ReplyDelete
I actually found the book quite heartening in its description of efforts to save endangered species. Obviously we need more drastic efforts to address global warming.Delete
Sometimes we have to look for ways that people are actively trying to save the environment and its living creatures. Yes, the consequences of good intentions and a failure to look at long term outcomes has been a problem. I am often surprised and happy to see that many good ideas come from high school and college students.ReplyDelete
It's encouraging that so many are thinking about the issues and indeed devoting their lives to them. We just need to develop the political will to match and support the efforts of these heroes.Delete
I'm sure Kolbert does a great service researching & writing these books ... about many things that are dire on the planet. It's good she includes some hopeful parts ... I need to look up a pupfish !ReplyDelete
I was frankly entranced by the pupfish story.Delete