At Night All Blood is Black by David Diop: A review
It is a short book, only 192 pages. I was able to read it in one day, virtually in one sitting. Its brevity proved to be a very good thing because I'm not sure how much more I could have taken. The writing is incredibly intense and the story that it tells is one of unspeakable horror and tragedy.
The gist of that story is this: The time and place are World War I in the trenches of France. Alfa Ndiaye is an African legionnaire fighting for France. Fighting alongside him is his best friend, Mademba. But then his friend is fatally wounded in battle. In fact, he is disemboweled and as he lies wounded on the field, he begs his friend Ndiaye to put an end to his suffering by slitting his throat. But Ndiaye cannot find it within himself to do that and so he stays by his friend until the end, trying to comfort him as he dies in agony. Ndiaye is filled with guilt over the incident and his spiritual burden soon unhinges his mind. His time in the trenches becomes a macabre drama. Each night he sneaks away from his comrades and captures a German soldier whom he immobilizes and disembowels and as the man screams in agony, Ndiaye slits his throat. Afterward, he chops off the man's hand as a trophy to take back to his unit.
At first, his comrades and superiors are happy with his actions. As he plays the savage, he strikes terror in their enemys' hearts. But when he continues to do this night after night, his fellow African troops begin to see him as a "devourer of souls" and they become terrified of him. By the time he returns with a seventh hand, their French captain has seen enough. The unit commander sends him to a psychiatric hospital to be treated. Slowly, under the care of a French doctor, the horror in his mind begins to recede and he approaches normal once again. He recalls his vivid memories of his mother whom he adored and who disappeared when he was a child. Now he falls in love with a young woman, but that love like the relationship he had with his mother is not to last.
The central theme of the story is a man trying to understand himself and what he owes others. What does he owe to friends and what does he owe to enemies and are those two things really the same? How does one interpret the ethical questions of life? The story turns somewhat mystical and philosophical at the end, but it is a story that, in spite of its horror, is very hard to put down. The writing is really that good.
My rating: 4 of 5 stars
I always enjoy checking out Obamas summer list. From his 2021 list I have Project Hail Mary and Klara and the Sun but they are still on my unread shelf. "At Night All That Blood" certainly sounds powerful and dark but something about it still makes it sound like a contemplative read.ReplyDelete
"Contemplative" is a good word to describe it.Delete
I love Obama's reading lists. We always share at least a few and I always look forward to his next one!ReplyDelete
He hasn't steered me wrong yet.Delete
When I was younger, I enjoyed reading horror and tragedy, but in my declining years I prefer something much lighter. I don't feel this book is for me even though it is well written. P. xReplyDelete
I understand and feel much as you do. But I do like to challenge myself from time to time.Delete
I'm not sure I'm up for the horrifying aspects in this one. Especially not right now when there are so many horrifying things going on in the world. But Ndiaye sounds like a very complex and unforgettable character.ReplyDelete
He is that.Delete
WOW. This definitely sounds like a very deep and dark book, but I want to read it so bad!ReplyDelete
It's certainly worth the effort if you can tolerate the darkness.Delete
Even though this book sounds like it is far out of my comfort zone, it also sounds like a book that packs a punch.ReplyDelete
Right to the solar plexus. It sort of leaves you gasping for air, but also thinking about what you've just read.Delete
The questions are good ones to ponder. The effects of war is something we don't always want to understand. The trenches in France really brought out the individual tragedies of even survival and made the medical profession aware of the injuries to the mind.ReplyDelete
For some years, I've been reading the Charles Todd mystery series featuring Inspector Ian Rutledge which highlights the horror of the war and the injuries to the mind in a somewhat gentler way than this book does. Rutledge continues to suffer from what was then called "shell shock" three years after the end of the war - which is where the series is now. It is pretty well researched series for those interested in that period.Delete
A very dark and heavy story packed into less than 200 pages. It sounds like a story well worth the effort of getting through the darkness.ReplyDelete
It is definitely a worthwhile read.Delete