Well, that was something completely different. I don't usually read graphic novels. I'm a word person and I prefer stories told with words rather than illustrations. But this one was recommended to me for its humor and in the interest of broadening my reading horizons, I decided to give it a try.
I don't really know how typical this is of graphic novels. The drawings have an unfinished look about them and they leave a lot to the imagination. They illustrate anecdotes from the author's life, so this is in a sense a graphic memoir. That makes it a twofer for me: I don't usually read memoirs and I don't usually read graphic novels, so I'm breaking into whole new territory here.
The book comprises a series of essays relating the author's anecdotes. These start when she is three years old. She tells us that she became obsessed with her next-door neighbor, a middle-aged man, and she essentially began stalking him. Yes, I know. A three-year-old stalker boggles the mind a bit, but I'm not sure how else I can describe it. She stands in the driveway of her home staring at her neighbor while he is out and about in his yard.
While her parents are away at work, her babysitter locks the doors of the house so that her charge will not accidentally get outside, but little Allie discovers that she can escape the house by going through the doggie door and she's off to the races! At first, she contents herself with merely observing her neighbor, but then she finds that his house has a cat door and that she can enter the house through that door. She visits the house both during the day and at night and she starts taking small items from there and hiding them in her drawer. (Again I remind you this is a three-year-old doing all this.) Eventually, she is discovered and must face consequences.
She tells us that she gains a baby sister who she hates at first. But the sister grows on her. They become allies and friends and Allie ends up adoring her. As adults, when tragedy strikes that sister it is completely devastating to Allie and causes her own life to go off the rails. She suffers from depression. Her marriage falls apart. She becomes self-destructive, dabbling in various drugs and considering ending it all.
For a book that I was told would be humorous, very many of the stories it contained just seemed terribly sad to me. I got the impression in some instances that the writer/illustrator was striving to laugh at herself and her experiences and to get us to laugh at them but she might have been better served by simply acknowledging the sadness that she felt rather than trying to laugh it away.
That being said, there are moments of pure humor but they don't occur that frequently for me in this 520-page book. Looking at some of the Goodreads readers' reviews of the book reveals that many of them would disagree with me and found the book quite funny. Perhaps my sense of humor is deficient.
So, my foray into reading graphic novels was somewhat less than successful. That's not an indictment of the genre and I may try again at some point, but I freely admit that I am prejudiced and my prejudice is for words. Describe your story with words and let me draw my own mind pictures.
My rating: 3 of 5 stars
I have never tried a graphic novel, Dorothy, but I suspect that my reaction would be the same as yours.
ReplyDeleteAs I said I don't want to indict the entire genre, but this one did not impress me.
DeleteI love picture books, and I enjoy illustrated books for adults, but graphic novels...generally annoy me. The text is reduced to dialogue that is often banal and brief, and I prefer to imagine a scene, a character rather than have it defined in pictures. I will say that reading a graphic novel of a complex book (Moby Dick, for example, and The Divine Comedy) helped me make my way through the book much like a movie might.
ReplyDeleteI have 182 books currently on my Favorites shelf on Goodreads, and though many of them are picture books and illustrated children's books, none of them are graphic novels.
I wonder if I am too old to appreciate them.
For someone who enjoys children's picture books, I think it is unlikely that being too old is your problem, although I admit it might have something to do with my failure to appreciate.
DeleteI like your recounting of this adventure you took into uncharted territory for you. I share your feelings about making my own pictures. That is why I like to read a book before I see the movie.
ReplyDeleteI find that the scenes and the characters that I paint for myself never quite match up with the filmmakers' vision.
DeleteI love children's books, picture books but, never could get into graphic novels. Personally, I wonder if that is because I never enjoyed comic strips as a child or adult either?
ReplyDeleteActually, I loved comic books when I was little. In fact, in my early years, other than the picture books my parents got me, comic books were mostly what I had access to read. But I moved on from that when I had the chance and I don't see myself becoming a big fan of graphic works.
DeleteI like graphic novels and manga and this doesn't sound like something I'd like either! If you ever decide to jump into another graphic novel, I hope it's better than this one!
ReplyDeleteI'm confident this was not really a fair representative of the genre.
DeleteThanks for bringing this to my attention, Dorothy! I hope that I will like it, because I'm adding it to my TBR.
ReplyDeleteI do recognize myself and my family in laughing things away. We've suffered loads of losses, some bigger than the others and we've gotten used to it by making jokes. Even my grandma was making jokes while she was on her death bed... Sometimes it's maybe a coping mechanism? But it does get unhealthy, I think, if you never allow yourself to cry!
What I like is that I'm already thinking about this book, but I've not even touched it yet... Thank you for doing that with your review!
I hope you enjoy it, Esther. Again, judging by comments on Goodreads, many readers have.
DeleteI have branched out into graphic novels and find them to be hit or miss. Although, I have mostly had good experiences. Like you, I began reading graphic novels as a way to expand my reading horizons.
ReplyDeleteI have heard of Allie Brosh and she seems well regarded/liked in terms of her written work, but I have the feeling my reaction would be the same as yours to Solutions and Other Problems.
I have read that she is generally a well-regarded writer of graphics.
Delete